I was wondering, what does a virgin feel like? I am way past the point in life where I will ever know, but I have always been curious.
Having been blessed with small and thin most of my life, all women felt similar - not tight, that's for sure. There are the big ones who have given birth recently or have big ex-BFs, then there were the younger ones who felt a little smaller. But 5x4.5"does not stretch anything. An old mate of mine (who was well endowed) used to hunt, and get virgins because he enjoyed the tightness.
So all you experienced cherry poppers out there - please tell all in detail.
Tightness and how it loosed off over time and how long it took her to loosen.
Also depth and how it stretched over how much time.
In answering, detail about the thickness and length of your cock will give your answer more meaning.